Volume 1, Number 2


EDM: The Missing Link in BCS


Integration of the engineering environment with business control systems offers competitive advantage to manufacturers

By Ken Cooper and Maurice Plourde

For discrete manufacturers, business control systems (BCS) are playing an ever-increasing role in managing the enterprise. An initiative that began almost two decades ago to control supply inventories (MRP) and then plant-wide resources (MRP II), has now worked its way into every aspect of production and distribution.

Two new arrivals on the BCS scene -- enterprise resource planning (ERP) and supply chain management (SCM) -- are rapidly becoming the terms of choice for describing manufacturing management as a whole. Manufacturing information systems, once directed exclusively toward inventory management, have grown to encompass quoting, product configuration, shop floor scheduling, financials, distribution logistics and more.

At the same time, computer-aided design and engineering (CAD & CAE) have been developing in parallel, driving the automation of design and engineering to include comprehensive product databases, on-line drawings and documentation, and engineering change orders. Until recently, however, the valuable stores of data created by the engineering side of the manufacturing enterprise were largely inaccessible to users seeking to broaden data integration throughout the business by means of BCS systems.


Integrated business control systems
Early MRP II pioneers who attempted to bridge this gap often paid dearly for their initiatives. Custom programming, once a commonplace in the BCS marketplace, carried high overhead costs coming and going. This recognition led to the development by suppliers of integrated business control systems built around a common database and integrated application set.

These standard systems are feature rich, meet a wide variety of functional needs, and while amenable to modification and further integration on an "as needed" basis, are often run largely unmodified. Well suited for make-to-order as well as continuous manufacturing environments, such systems meet a wide spectrum of needs ranging from rapid implementation to business process re-engineering (BPR) -- or simply transitioning out of non-adaptive, expensive-to-maintain legacy systems into more economical and efficient alternatives.

Yet, a gateway and staging area for mustering, assembling and reviewing product information within the overall context of the BCS is called for. This need has been met with the advent of integrated engineering data management (EDM), a modular component of advanced BCS that has proven itself to be of significant value in such areas as:

  • Computer-aided process planning (CAPP). In the emerging area of production engineering, CAPP represents a step forward in process planning and development in terms of sequence, step and transfer methodology. Recent attention has switched from automation to cycle time reduction -- particularly with respect to workcells. Central to CAPP is an easy means for notating, documenting and revising process plans.

  • Drawing management (DM). Virtually every manufacturing operation relies on volumes of shop drawings for everything from machine set-up to assembly and engineering changes. The retrieval and storage of drawings has historically been tedious and even overwhelming, leading to inaccuracies and outright errors. Transforming drawings into on-line images suitable for cataloging, indexing and retrieval typically relies on the integration of a CAD system with shop floor control into an enterprise resource planning software package. The benefits of such an approach are substantial.

  • Concurrent engineering. The continuing demand for reduced cycle times has led to the creation of an on-line repository of engineering information accessible to departments throughout the enterprise. Design, engineering, production, distribution and other departments can all access the "standards" (product data, assembly procedures, etc.) without overstepping functional boundaries. Thus, work flow is facilitated through commonly-viewed change orders and scheduling revisions. In a word, everyone can "read from the same page," without crowding each other away from the book.

  • Document management. As distinct from drawings, documents tend to be character-based, making them easier than drawings to store and access. Once input is placed on- line, such functionality can prove itself invaluable. Individuals and teams can access and verify the carrying out of procedures, some containing significant instructional content. Quality assurance, verification and logging all benefit from efficient document management.


    A significant step forward
    The availability of on-line engineering data within the business planning environment represents a significant step forward in the evolution of manufacturing systems. The use of powerful, fully accessible databases is finally fulfilling the promise of CAD/CAM, a concept so long in coming to fruition as to be almost antiquated. Yet with the introduction of DM, the engineering-business planning gap is finally closed.

    In practice this means sales and marketing managers have access to a whole library of engineering information, including parts availabilities, configuration options and pricing information that directly reduces quotation development and time-to-promise. Such a capability represents a distinct competitive advantage for those whose manufacturing style is make- or configure-to-order.

    With a DM capability directly linked to a central database, field sales personnel -- previously subject to endless rounds of back-and-forth with the factory as quotations are developed and revised -- can configure and quote more readily at the point of sale. This is a significant advantage for those seeking to compress the sales cycle.

    In combination with a rules-based product configurator (also known as a "smart" quotation), field sales personnel can effectively drive the whole manufacturing operation on behalf of a prospective client. Using laptop PCs loaded with modular applications, field sales personnel can review parts inventories and assembly/configuration time-to-deliver.

    This is achieved through the accessing of a knowledge base built around "best design" and "best practices" algorithms derived from authoritative engineering methods and experiences. In bringing a sale to a close in capital equipment and other configure- or build-to-order industries, such an approach allows for timely quotations and time-to-promise that was unheard of a recently as a few years ago.


    Applications
    Examples of companies making use of product data management include an international manufacturer of telecommunications equipment whose products are subject to a continuing stream of engineering change orders (ECOs). Such circumstances have lead to the development of a system which integrates all assembly procedures, shop drawings, documents (including ECOs and assembly procedures) and serial parts tracking on line.

    Another application is that of a manufacturer of testing equipment whose products are heavily configured, yet whose marketplace is highly competitive. Field sales personnel are now calling order specifications to the factory where "editors" are able to quote and provide time-to-deliver information on demand. Such functionality will soon move into the field on portable PCs.


    Impacting cycle time
    Indeed, EDM positively impacts the whole issue of cycle time reduction throughout the manufacturing organization. Concurrent engineering initiatives in the form of engineering change orders become directly visible to all members of the organization with a need to know. Expedited document distribution smoothes work flow, by making engineering procedures available to both planning and production departments -- an enhancement to BCS from prototyping and ramp-up to production runs that increasingly include customized or special order elements.

    Further, with knowledge of standard hours, procedures and processes in hand, the production planner and cost accountant are better prepared to deal with the increasing variability of scheduling and cost analysis. Variations on this theme include "executive information systems," whose ability to highlight trends and factors lends support to capital planning and budgeting. In an age when "mass customization" is throwing traditional cost accounting into disarray, having an alternative to activity-based costing is a decided advantage.


    Adapting to market demand
    Consider the situation of a production planner in a capital goods manufacturing enterprise who must reconcile erratic order flow and enterprise resources. Likewise, consider an assembly engineer working with a complex bill of materials, a variety of drawing references and engineering protocols. A "paperless" operation attuned to the equipment demands of both production operations and an order flow that may or may not go "live" at some indeterminate time in the future can add significantly in reconciling workcells and other production resources to work flow.

    This helps the organization adapt more readily to market demand in both the short term (production planning) and long term (capital planning). With tightly coupled EDM/BCS the manufacturing organization becomes more flexible and responsive.

    For the information systems executive who as part of the management team is charged with re-engineering the organization or effecting continuous improvement programs, integrated EDM/BCS offers numerous advantages, not the least being access to a more comprehensive set of on-line summary reports.

    With product content and production processes closely linked to order entry, trends impacting capital equipment costs, workforce and facilities become subject to easier and more precise analysis. With more and more manufacturers taking a custom- and build-to-order approach, making pre-engineering data and other strategic information more visible is another plus for EDM.


    New strength
    Such capabilities meet the overall criteria underlying strategic transformation: desirability, integration consistency and flexibility. This lends new strength to manufacturers whose product development plans are driven by the constant need for enhanced features, functionality and reliability in the face of unending cost competitiveness.

    Recent studies have shown that Japanese manufacturers devote almost 50 percent more effort to product development than their Western counterparts -- a further affirmation, if one is needed at all, that to whatever extent product development and production tactics can be linked, customer satisfaction will be enhanced.


    Ken Cooper is general manager of Interactive Group, a vendor of business control systems with offices in Watford, near London. Maurice Plourde is a director of research & development for Interactive Group.


  • Return to the Table of Contents
  • Go to the CiME homepage
  • Go to the Lionheart Publishing homepage
  • Go to the Subscription Form for the print edition of CiME.


    CiME © is a publication of Lionheart Publishing, Inc.

    2555 Cumberland Parkway, Suite 299
    Atlanta, GA 30339 USA
    Phone: +44 23 8110 3411

    e-mail:
    URL: http://207.69.204.147